G.W. Cottrell was a successful Boston bookseller and stationer who produced one of the most well-known planchettes during the Great Planchette Craze of 1868. Boston was one of the primary epicenters of the craze, and the locale where C.H. Farley first brought his writing planchettes from Portland Maine to sell at Boston’s Cretan Fair in April, 1868. While Farley considered the event a failure, his leftover inventory was left for sale in the city as he sought out others who might want to pursue manufacturing planchettes on a larger scale, and the devices soon began to catch on as the Once a Week planchette article that had sparked the craze in England the prior year made its rounds through American newspaper.
Cottrell was initially a sales agent of Kirby & Co. of New York, one of America’s first planchette makers with whom C.H. Farley had partnered. But the partnership offered no exclusivity to their agents, and all who cared to order their products were welcome to, and period advertisements reveal that the “stationer’s row” street where Cottrell was but one of dozens of booksellers, became flooded with Kirby & Co. planchettes as they all sought to capitalize on the fad. Kirby & Company struggled to keep up with demand, and by June, Cottrell reported to local newspapers that “so much is planchette in demand” and he was “hard pressed to answer orders.” Cottrell sought other wholesalers, and began stocking Jenning’s competing Little Wonder planchette before commissioning a jobber to design a new planchette so that he could act as their sole agent, calling it the Boston Planchette.
Advertised in three versions, including a black walnut board that sold for $1.00, a rosewood model with “handsome, fretted work” at $2.00, and “beautifully painted” hollywood model for $3.00, Cottrell undercut Kirby & Co.’s pricing with a more affordable castor design that ads claimed “reduces the cost of Planchette one-half the former price.” Although the stamped metal components were not up to the quality standard of their competitor’s turned brass castors, they could be manufactured cheaply and quickly, with coarse threads that screwed directly into the boards’ tops with no other required hardware, sidestepping several production issues—and others soon adopted the design. The walnut and rosewood models of Boston Planchettes are not uncommon, although no known specimens of the hollywood model have been documented. All surviving examples carry either a classic heart shape or a more distinctive shield shape, which is likely the refined shape carried over from the original Parisian planchettes, as that is the model Cottrell chose to have illustrated for marketing and packaging,a nd which would be inherited by Selchow & Righter for their Scientific Planchettes a generation later, and subsequently by W.S. Reed Toy Company for both their writing planchettes and the indicator of their early Ouija competitor, Espirito.
Despite having no patent or proprietary claims to planchettes, Kirby & Co. took Cottrell’s Boston Planchette as a personal affront, with C. H. Farley was particularly vocal about the seeming betrayal, telling one reporter how “Mr. Cottrell, the manager of the ‘Boston planchette’ business, got his idea from them, being formerly their agent,” and another how Cottrell had “got from them the particulars of the manufacture, and then turned his back on them and got out what he calls the Boston Planchette.” Cottrell’s move was hardly unusual, particularly as no one could claim propriety on the well-publicized French invention. Nevertheless, Kirby and Co. vied for the prestige of being the “original Jacobs,” and attacked Cottrell heavily in the press. Even G. W. Cottrell’s promotional booklet, Revelations of Planchette, became a point of contention for Farley, who publicly accused Cottrell of co-opting materials he and the Kirby brothers had collected for their own use.
Cottrell also pulled a clever propriety trick to push back against Kirby & Co.’s infringement claims: He owned one of the original Parisian-inspired planchettes Dr. H. F. Gardner and Robert Dale Owen had manufactured in Boston nine years before, which he put on prominent display in his storefront, which one reporter noted it looked “very much like the modern P’s, though not quite so elegant in appearance.” The precursor item undermined Kirby & Co.’s claims of impropriety, and to further promote the idea that his planchettes had a heritage dating back several years prior to his competitor’s claims, he boldly printed “From the original pattern, first made in Boston in 1860” in advertisements and on his planchettes’ labels. It appears to have worked, if it mattered at all during the red-hot craze, and soon Cottrell was busy fulfilling orders for “thousands and thousands of her to all parts of the country,” acutely recognizing that the nuance of propriety was likely lost on customers who wanted only to get their hands on the country’s hottest fad.
Cottrell’s Boston Planchette remained on the market well into the 1870s, secure in a legacy of being one of the most recognizable planchettes of the great craze.