Skip to content
 

Chapter 3: Birth of the Talking Board

Chapter 3: Birth of the Talking Board

After planchette's First Great Craze of the late 1860s, the devices suffered a sharp decline in the 1870s, which proved to be a difficult decade for Spiritualism as the movement continued to be fraught with controversy over the exposure of materializing mediums that dampened the public’s enthusiasm for séances and the tools of spirit communication. Occasional sensational stories of planchettes’ predictions bolstered interest, but it may be that the laborious task of deciphering scribbled spirit writing grew wearisome, as new innovations more often than not relied on some method of indicating alphabets, harkening back to the earliest uses of alphabet cards in séances.

One was Richard Bewley’s “New Indicator,” featured in an 1871 edition of Medium & Daybreak, where its creator proposed constructing a special tray printed with an alphabet that would guide a user’s planchette from letter to letter rather than writing messages with a pencil. Five years later, an account in the American Spiritual Magazine told of the "easiest means of intercourse" one family used to communicate with their son that involved an alphabet-painted table and a rod-shaped indicator, hinting at the alphabetic innovations lingering on the horizon.

Wagner-style Psychographs also saw a resurgence in Europe, with multiple manufacturers offering them for sale. Lawyer and Civil War veteran General Francis J. Lippitt, a close friend and confidant of Helena Patrovna Blavatsky, introduced an alphabetic spirit-spelling table in this period he called the Psychic Stand, and publicly sparred with the US Patent office in a failed bid to patent the apparatus, with the office declining to issue approval since they believed doing so would given official government endorsement of Spiritualism.

Richard Bewley’s “New Indicator,” depicted in the January 27, 1871 edition of Medium & Daybreak.
Richard Bewley’s “New Indicator,” depicted in the January 27, 1871 edition of Medium & Daybreak.
The “L. K.” Alphabet Table, American Spiritual Magazine, March 1877.
The “L. K.” Alphabet Table, American Spiritual Magazine, March 1877.

As the 1870s gave way to the 1880s, interest in spiritual matters rekindled, bringing with it the bright promise of new innovations in spirit communications tools. Frederick Becker patented his “Device for Amusement and Instruction” in the first year of the new decade, proposing an ingenious sliding plate that moved an indicator over an alphabet, although it is unknown if he ever produced the design commercially. Planchettes began to experience a new revival of interest in early 1884.

Newspapers began to report how “Spiritualism, table-rapping, and planchette writing have been engaging and amusing our young people for a week or two past,” and later that year a widely-reprinted article titled “The Wonderful Planchette” appeared in newspapers across the America, describing planchettes’ former fad, detailing their use, and hinting at the fortune made by the Kirby brothers during the 1868 craze. The revival spread into the next year, as newspapers once again embraced the writing devices with headlines and enthusiastic articles, and companies like Jaques & Son and James G. Stormont in England and E.G. Selchow, George Blackie & Company, and Colby & Rich in America introduced a new generation of planchettes to market.

Frederick Becker’s “Device for Amusement and Instruction,” U.S. Patent 233,198, October 12, 1880.
Frederick Becker’s “Device for Amusement and Instruction,” U.S. Patent 233,198, October 12, 1880.
A Jaques & Son planchette, paired with one of the company’s earliest planchette advertisements, 1879.
A Jaques & Son planchette, paired with one of the company’s earliest planchette advertisements, 1879.
In early 1886, headlines exploded around the country as news of the “New Planchette” spread like wildfire.
In early 1886, headlines exploded around the country as news of the “New Planchette” spread like wildfire.

Planchettes’ revival would be short-circuited by a new innovation in spirit communication. Perhaps inspired by this renewed interest, Spiritualist circles in Akron, Ohio took a similar route as Richard Bewley had a few years prior, and began to merge the concept of writing planchettes with specialized boards that closely resembled the alphabet cards long used in séances, with the planchette now used in a secondary role as an indicator to point out messages.

This pairing spread from Akron into other communities in Northern Ohio, including Canton, Elyria, Mansfield, Tiffin, Warren, Youngstown, where all were experiencing “a perfect craze over the new planchette.” Soon, a report simply titled “Another Planchette” appeared in the February 21, 1886 edition of the Cincinnati Enquirer.

The article quoted local iron industry executive Jeremiah A. Long of Akron, who described how “the whole town has been filled with the machines,” which he described as rectangular boards that were “usually about two feet by eighteen inches, on which were placed all the letters of the alphabet.” Long described the planchette-like indicator as “a little table with three legs on small rollers,” and went on to describe the familiar use of the board once sitters placed the indicator on it: “Two persons sit down with their finger tips on this table.

One of them asks a question to which an answer is desired. Then they await the action of the little table, to which their fingers are glued,” before describing how “that table will fly around at times” as the indicator pointed out “wonderful and strikingly pertinent answers.” Long claimed the “bewitched and mysterious pieces of mechanism” made his family so nervous that “they could hardly sleep at night,” and so he “smashed it up for kindling wood.”

1886 articles detailed—and sometimes illustrated—the new alphabetic spirit apparatus in use among Spiritualists of Northern Ohio, which some
1886 articles detailed—and sometimes illustrated—the new alphabetic spirit apparatus in use among Spiritualists of Northern Ohio, which some papers dubbed the “Talking Board.”

Luckily, others were also experimenting with the new apparatus, and the article quickly spread to other outlets and attracted other inquisitive reporters. The Des Moines Register reprinted it five days later as “A New Sort of Planchette,” and appeared the same day in the Macon Telegraph as “A Strange Thing. Planchette with Quite a Number of Improvements.”

Papers in Pennsylvania and Ohio invoked this new incarnation of planchette with headlines like “A Wonderful New Planchette,” and “A New Species of Planchette,” while the Chicago Tribune ran the story in early March as “A Mysterious Piece of Mechanism,” with papers across Kansas, Missouri, South Carolina, and Wisconsin following suit.

This early coverage paled in comparison to the publicity generated by an expanded, illustrated version of the article that appeared in the New York Daily Tribune a little over a month later. Titled "The New ‘Planchette.’ A Mysterious Talking Board and Table Over Which Northern Ohio is Agitated," this sensational new story finally gave the enigmatic devices a name—the talking board—and began with a dismissive challenge to the then-resurgent writing planchette: “Planchette is simply nowhere compared with the new scheme for mysterious communication that is being used out in Ohio” before launching into evocative details of the “remarkable things” he witnessed involving the boards “that seem to pass all human comprehension or explanation.”

A talking board in use, from the Warren Daily Mirror, April 8, 1886.
A talking board in use, from the Warren Daily Mirror, April 8, 1886.

Hundreds of newspapers reprinted variations of both reports, and the sensational articles appeared as far afield as England, Australia, New Zealand.

The accounts found their way to the Spiritualist press, and the Religio-Philosophical Journal carried a report on the creation of wounded Civil War veteran Isaac Taylor Damon of Millington, Michigan, who paired a planchette-like indicator with “an unpainted wooden board 18x24 inches, with the alphabet stenciled upon it in three horizontal lines, the words “‘Yes’ and ‘No,’ ‘I don’t know,’ and the numerals beneath it.” Damon’s friend, I.R. Armstrong of East Fletcher, Vermont also created a board of his own, and encouraged other readers to build their own boards, after having positive experiences communicating with “spirits disembodied.” Armstrong’s report similarly inspired dentist W.O. Pierce of Winchester, Indiana, who created his “lap planchette,” which he described as a 24x16-inch flat wooden board with 2-inch wide wooden bars around the perimeter meant to “exclude light from underneath.” Over this basic framework was stretched two layers of heavy manila paper printed with letters, numbers, and the words “Yes,” “No,” and “Good Night,” all of which formed a “miniature table suitable for the lap, at which four persons may be comfortably seated.”

The group used a “pencil or indicator to trace the letters,” which would “peck away at the alphabet like an English sparrow hungry for corn.”

Hudson Tuttle alongside three surviving examples of his Psychograph, or Dial Planchette, which his family manufactured from 1886 to the 1910
Hudson Tuttle alongside three surviving examples of his Psychograph, or Dial Planchette, which his family manufactured from 1886 to the 1910s.

As with planchettes before them, these articles sparked the imaginations of a number of entrepreneurs who rushed to market with new alphabetic spirit-spelling devices.

One was Thomas Lees, owner of Lee’s Bazaar, a “Spiritual, Occult, and Liberal Literature Agency” in Cleveland, who introduced his Psychobrette, or Spirit Talking Board in September 1886.

Pitched as the “Evolution of Planchette!,” the Psychobrette—commonly misspelled in ads as “Psychorbrette,” “Psycho-brette,” “Psychorette,” and even “Psycho-Spiritette”—consisted of a wooden board with a pasted paper alphabet and a wheeled rectangular planchette fitted with a small metal indicator, which rolled back and forth on the board to point to figures and spell messages from beyond.

Lees’ friend, the famous Spiritualist Hudson Tuttle of Berlin Heights, Ohio, also introduced one of the movement’s most enduring séance tools at this time: the Psychograph, or Dial Planchette, which greatly resembled Holmes ’ Alphabetic Planchette from the 1868 craze.

Several inventors introduced new forms of talking boards in the wake of the 1886 craze, including Thomas Lees’ Psychobrette, George W. Kates
Several inventors introduced new forms of talking boards in the wake of the 1886 craze, including Thomas Lees’ Psychobrette, George W. Kates’ Talking Board & Planchette Combined, and the unattributed “Dancing Derby,” the news of which garnered headlines across the country.

Other creations followed. Rev. George W. Kates of Dark County, Ohio, a prominent Spiritualist minister, introduced his Talking Board & Planchette Combined in late 1888, which combined a writing planchette made with “improved and durable castors” with an alphabet board for spelling out messages, which he pitched as “of great aid to spirit communion.”

The Theosophical Library of San Francisco who pitched their Mysterious Talking Table and Board as “Better than the Planchette. Edifying and Amusing,” and as far away as London, Earnest Westlake, a director of the Hypnotic Committee for the Society of Psychical Research, introduced his Westlake Dial Planchette and the Westlake Psychoscope. In Chicago, a “Mrs. Brown” paired 2-inch wooden alphabet tiles with a specially prepared hat with wooden legs that acted as an indicator that newspapers dubbed the “Dancing Derby,” which she considered patenting, although it is unknown if she ever produced the device commercially.

W.S. Reed Toy Company executives, including founder W.S. Reed and company treasurer Charles E. Dresser, pictured left, used the sudden popul
W.S. Reed Toy Company executives, including founder W.S. Reed and company treasurer Charles E. Dresser, pictured left, used the sudden popularity of talking boards to stage a publicity stunt and send a “witch board” to President Grover Cleveland as a wedding gift, and would revisit the idea 6 years later with their Espirito, or Revelator board.

In what may represent the burgeoning toy industry’s most startling missed opportunities, the W.S. Reed Toy Company of Leominster, Massachusetts saw in the immense press talking boards had received an opportunity not for a product, but rather a publicity stunt. Rather than rushing to production, the firm produced what they called a “Witch Board” with the idea of sending it to none other than President Grover Cleveland as a wedding gift, the news of which had just erupted across the nation’s newspapers. Company treasurer Charles E. Dresser summoned reporters from the Boston Globe to cover the “peculiar present” he was sending to the White House, and the article described Reed’s “piece of spiritualized lumber” in detail: “Upon the four corners of the board are respectively ‘Yes,’ ‘No,’ ‘Good-by,’ and ‘Good-day,’ while the alphabet occupies the centre of the board. A miniature standard, which rests upon four legs, stands upon the ‘witch board,’ upon which the hands are placed, and then the spirits begin their work.” The publicity ploy worked, with the entertaining account spreading along America’s East Coast and as far west as Montana, and Cleveland responded in jest, stating emphatically that “I hardly think that I shall immediately test its power to disclose the past and forecast the future.” Despite the original article’s reporter seeing grand commercial potential for the Witch Board’s popularity, Reed does not seem to have capitalized on the idea beyond the publicity stunt, indicating a costly misstep in anticipating consumer demand that would soon come back to haunt the company, particularly as other ambitious entrepreneurs mobilized to bring new talking board visions to market, as the birth of Ouija loomed on the horizon.