Skip to content
 

Chapter 5: New Crazes, New Battles

Chapter 5: New Crazes, New Battles
William Fuld, 1920s.

The turn of the century brought with it a fresh wave of innovation in spirit communication apparatus.

Planchettes maintained a significant cultural cache. While many of its competitors had come and gone over the last decade, Ouija managed to embed itself in the popular psyche in a way other spirit mechanisms did not.

The evocative name it had granted itself beneath the fingers of Helen Peters carried a certain je ne sais quoi—an elusive, indefinable quality that perfectly encapsulated the enigmatic board—and helped it navigate a downturn of interest until heads turned once more to it.

William Fuld, 1920s. ►

Artifacts of the Fuld Feud Era, including Ouija, now showcasing a new style of heart or shield-shaped planchette on long, woodturned legs, a
Artifacts of the Fuld Feud Era, including Ouija, now showcasing a new style of heart or shield-shaped planchette on long, woodturned legs, and a stencil used by Isaac Fuld after the break from his brother, where he snipped out the Ouija logo to replace it with the near-identical Oriole logo for his new model of talking board.

Not all was well among Ouija’s makers. Since 1897, production had been handled by the partnership of brothers William and Isaac Fuld, trading under the name Isaac Fuld & Brother, but the new century found the pair catering to a steeply diminished slate of vendors as Ouija sales remained sluggish.

By the end of 1900, their alliance began to quickly crumble into a litigious and bitter end. When Isaac determined that his brother was owed more in royalties than the company was due from vendors, he declined to issue the payments. The move, likely combined with other unknown personal conflicts, caused William to break from the partnership.

With a more established relationship with the former directors of the Ouija Novelty Company who had leased Ouija production rights to the pair, William secretly negotiated a new agreement directly with his old bosses and dissolved the partnership, striking out on his own to produce Ouija under his own name.

Isaac saw the move as a total betrayal, and continued manufacturing Ouija from his home workshop on Ensor St., in direct infringement on the patents and trademarks William had just secured. At the end of 1901, William filed an injunction in Baltimore’s Circuit Court No. 2 to stop Isaac’s production, who dodged infringement claims by clipping the old Ouija logo from brass stencils used to produce the boards, and replacing it with his new “Oriole” tradename, escalating a bitter dispute that would simmer unresolved for the next two decades.

While Ouija’s fortune wavered, planchettes sprung once more into the limelight as the result of another high-profile court battle, this time in England. Known as the Cavendish Trial or the Great Planchette Case, it involved a freewheeling young millionaire playboy and big game hunter named Henry Cavendish,.

Cavendish squandered his family fortune when he fell under the sway of a pair of unscrupulous mediums who used planchette communications—ostensibly from the spirit of his dearly departed mother—to convince him to sign away power of attorney and other financial rights to their séance coterie. When Cavendish’s estranged fiancé, the famous actress and postcard model Isabel Jay, uncovered the ruse, Cavendish sued the mediums to recover his stolen fortune. The salacious conflict sparked major headlines in the UK and America in 1903, and created a massive surge of interest in planchettes not seen since their first great craze.

In America, Selchow & Righter and E.I. Horsman were perfectly poised to take advantage of the reignited craze with their Scientific Planchette, with Selchow debuting a gorgeously-packaged “Mystic of Mystics” variant around this time.

Planchettes exploded once again in popularity after the Cavendish Planchette Trial of 1903, after the famous British playboy Henry Cavendish
Planchettes exploded once again in popularity after the Cavendish Planchette Trial of 1903, after the famous British playboy Henry Cavendish, show right, signed away his fortune to a pair of unscrupulous mediums who used planchette’s writings to pose as the spirit of Henry’s deceased mother, a plot uncovered by his famous fiancé, actress and model Isabel Jay, left.
England experienced an explosion of planchettes in the wake of the Cavendish Planchette Trial, including offerings from Chad Valley, Glevum
England experienced an explosion of planchettes in the wake of the Cavendish Planchette Trial, including offerings from Chad Valley, Glevum Games, Jaques & Son, R. Wyllie Hill & Co, F.H. Ayres, and others.

In Great Britain, the craze hit even harder. Veteran planchette manufacturers like Jaques & Son and F.H. Ayres, as well as new toy companies who had only had planchettes on the market a few short years, including R. Wyllie Hill & Company of Glasgow and London’s Robert Brothers, who traded as Glevum Games, were well-poised to take immediate advantage of the sudden surge of interest, as customers flocked to shop shelves to participate in the newly-revived fad for spirit apparatus.

One Sheffield Daily Telegraph article interviewed toy shop icons the Hamley Brothers, who then owned London’s oldest and most famous toy shop, Hamley’s, remarked that they were selling planchette by the hundreds, while newspapers declared Jaques & Son the leaders of the “Planchette Boom,” with articles reporting sales that jumped from “a few dozens weekly” to an estimated 4,000 per week.

Many British manufacturers printed special fold-out alphabet and message sheets to include with their planchettes, with evocative names like

Soon, other stalwarts of the British toy industry mobilized to meet the demands of the Cavendish surge, including George G. Bussey & Co. of London and Harborne’s Chad Valley Works, alongside a host of hastily assembled planchettes from opportunistic jobbers and underground factories who began rushing their own planchettes to desperate retailers, often assembled from the parts and packaging they were jobbing for the bigger toy concerns.Still other British planchettes remain unidentifiable despite carrying trademarked names, such as the “Eclipse Series” or “Royal Series” planchettes, which have have been the result of mainstream toymakers’ hesitancy to put their firm’s reputable name on a potentially disputable product, and their origins have remained obscure into the modern era.

◄ Many British manufacturers printed special fold-out alphabet and message sheets to include with their planchettes, with evocative names like Physio-Psychophone, Futuroscope & Mystereone, and Psychological Revealer.

One hallmark of British planchette manufacturers was their inclusion of a special fold-out alphabet and message sheet that many firms included with their planchettes, with evocative names like Physio-Psychophone, Futuroscope & Mystereone, and Psychological Revealer.

Manufacturers offered other options as well, including boxed sets for users to easily host Ask-the-Glass style séances, where instead of improvised alphabet cards and an upturned glass tumbler, consumers could now purchase the stylishly-packaged Vishnu from Hamley or the more obscure Rekrab, both of which came with pre-printed alphabet tiles and specialized etched glasses.

The Cavendish-inspired craze would eventually settle down, but new innovations in spirit communication continued in its wake, particularly in Great Britain. There, C.J. Smith introduced his Telesphere, or Psychic Table, with a built-in alphabet dial that turned as the table tipped, and W.T. Braham marketed his Wonderful Spirit Communicator. New patents appeared, including an intriguing roulette-inspired design from David Blaikley of Glasgow, which was introduced by Jaques & Son in 1909 as the Alpha. Not to be outdone, Parisian enthusiasts became enraptured with their own new spirit device development, the Oui-ja table, which French newspaper Le Monde Illustré reported sold as many as 20,000 units near decade’s end. American innovations continued as well, including the gorgeously-crafted Cablegraph from Spiritualist George Pearson, and Elijah Bond introduced a new talking board with the Nirvana, its release perfectly timed to exploit the expiration of the original Ouija patent he had designed that was now owned by William Fuld.

Alphabetic spirit-spelling tables of the turn-of-the-century included C.J. Smith’s Telesphere and the French “Oui-ja Table.”
New patented apparatus that emerged after the turn of the century included George Pearson’s Cablegraph and William Braham’s Telepathic Spiri
New patented apparatus that emerged after the turn of the century included George Pearson’s Cablegraph and William Braham’s Telepathic Spirit Communicator.

← Alphabetic spirit-spelling tables of the turn-of-the-century included C.J. Smith’s Telesphere and the French “Oui-ja Table.”

William Fuld updated Ouija’s logo around 1910, with a board of the era shown in use by the ladies of Winthrop University’s Ouija Club in 191

Intervening years saw spurts of popularity for both talking boards and planchettes, with new introductions from the Psycho Manufacturing Company, Blackpool’s Page & Company, the reintroduction of W.T. Braham’s invention with the Telepathic Spirit Communicator from Two Worlds Publishing, William W. Wheeler’s short-lived Wireless Messenger, and even an automatic writing planchette from Alexander Conlin, the infamous Crystal Seer and “Man Who Knows,” who put a lithograph of his own face on the planchette’s top.

In Japan, specialized talking boards made of paper with planchettes for coins would materialize as kokkuri, borrowing the name from the country’s earlier table tipping practices they had borrowed from the West.

William Fuld updated Ouija’s logo around 1910, with a board of the era shown in use by the ladies of Winthrop University’s Ouija Club in 1912. ►

Despite the lack of patent protections, William Fuld continued to invest in Ouija, as well as his new Oracle and Mystifying Oracle lines, and in late 1918 opened a massive new factory at 1508-1514 Harford, Lamont, and Federal streets in Baltimore. The move proved fortuitous when, in the wake of the twin tragedies of the World War I and the Great Influenza pandemic that same year, grief and loss awakened the public’s interest in esoteric matters once more, and Ouija would be swept once more into a years-long popular fad that would culminate in the iconic talking board reaching its cultural apex in 1920.

These years saw a massive surge of interest in Spiritualism and the occult, including the spirit-inspired novels of Patience Worth and Emily Hutchings, who channeled the spirits of Patience Worth and Mark Twain, respectively, through Ouija. Ouija presence was ubiquitous in media, where music, poems, comics, and stories of everyday encounters with Ouija and its miraculous revelations were omnipresent in newspapers and magazines of the day, including Norman Rockwell’s famous depiction of a courting couple at play with Ouija on the cover of the May 1, 1920 edition of the Saturday Evening Post.

Ouija was joined by the Mystifying Oracle line in the mid-1910s, and the designs of both the boards and their planchette indicators continue
Ouija was joined by the Mystifying Oracle line in the mid-1910s, and the designs of both the boards and their planchette indicators continued to evolve during this era.
William Fuld opened a massive new factory to produce Ouija at 1508-1514 Harford, Lamont, and Federal streets in Baltimore around 1918.
William Fuld opened a massive new factory to produce Ouija at 1508-1514 Harford, Lamont, and Federal streets in Baltimore around 1918.

Fuld faced an onslaught of competition as other companies clambered to satiate public demand, with some, like Wilder Manufacturing Company, J.M. Simmons, Morton Converse, and, predictably, his own brother, Isaac Fuld, directly challenging his patent and trademark claims both in the courtroom and in the court of public opinion, with a judge ultimately dealing a harsh blow that Ouija had become a “generic term,” as the companies began flooding the market with Ouija of their own. Charles Kennard himself would reemerge with a new talking board with the introduction of his Weird-A board, Theodore H. White debuted his I-DO-PSY-CHO-I-D-E-O-GRAPH, while the AuburnCompany introduced their Syco-Graf, Sunker Bisey invented his spirit typewriter, Alert Downe’s patent materialized as the Snitch Baby, Grover Haffner would take over Hollywood with his enigmatic Wanda Tipping Table, and Rosetta Almaide Robson introduced her Responda: The Talking Card & Pendulum, among many others. Planchettes would benefit from the groundswell of interest as well, including the Mystic Artist planchette from Jenness & Grove in America, and another popular craze in Great Britain, where the planchette had always proved more popular than the talking board, with the continued presence of stalwarts like Jaques & Son, Glevum Games, and Chad Valley now joined by new introductions from companies like H.P. Gibson, Weyers Brothers, and Two Worlds Publishing.

The talking board craze that followed the twin tragedies of World War I and the Great Influenza pandemic inspired many manufacturers to mark
The talking board craze that followed the twin tragedies of World War I and the Great Influenza pandemic inspired many manufacturers to market new designs, including, from top left to right: J.M. Simmons’ Ouija, Wilder Manufacturing Company’s Mitche Manitou, Psychic Research Association’s Telepah, J. W. Stanley Company’s Whitchy, Morton Converse’s Ouija, Southern Toy Company’s Ouija PPF, Supreme Brand Novelty's Mystic Board, and Unique Novelty Co.’s Gypsy Witch Myst-ry Board.
Charles Kennard re-entered the talking board market with his Weird-A board in 1919.
Charles Kennard re-entered the talking board market with his Weird-A board in 1919.
Theodore H. White’s I-DO-PSY-CHO-I-D-E-O-GRAPH, 1919.
Theodore H. White’s I-DO-PSY-CHO-I-D-E-O-GRAPH, 1919.
William Fuld’s “Electric” Mystifying Oracle, early 1930s.

On February 24, 1927, William Fuld tragically died after a fall from his factory roof, and his sons William Andrew and Paul Fuld and daughter Katherine Bowie Fuld stepped up to run the manufacturing company that bore their father’s name.

The death seemed to herald a sharp decline both in Ouija’s popularity and the development of new spirit communication apparatus, particularly in America, where products like John R. Donnelly’s Electra, Alfred Rees’ Mystic Dial, Hilda C. Enge’s Magic Wheel, Grace Gray DeLong’s ASK-IT, Decorative Arts Company’s Astro Talking Board, and the Voodoo Tipping Table from the American Manufacturing Concern were rare competition to the William Fuld company’s talking boards, who during this period primarily focused on their Mystifying Oracle line, and introduced such imaginative variations as their “Electric” Mystifying Oracle, with its all-metal construction and battery powered, light-enabled planchette.

◄ William Fuld’s “Electric” Mystifying Oracle, early 1930s.

The 1930s saw the introduction of many new spirit apparatus, including several new creations offered by Thomas Roden White’s Psychic Stores,
The 1930s saw the introduction of many new spirit apparatus, including several new creations offered by Thomas Roden White’s Psychic Stores, shown here through period Psychic News ads, and John R. Donnelly’s updated Electra board.

In Great Britain, innovation greatly outpaced American companies, and the 1930s represents one of the country’s greatest decades in the invention of séance apparatus. This was the era of the Ashkir-Jobson Trianon’s famous public séances with their Reflectograph, and the group created and sold such wonders as the Communigraph and the Séance Vibrator. The Vandermeulen Spirit Indicator, designed by the spirit of Henri Vendermeulen via the Ouija board, rang an alarm bell to signal the spirits’ presence and their willingness the engage in Ouija communications.

Companies introduced products with mysterious, compelling names, such as Two Worlds Publishing’s Phaino, Gabriel Dee’s Psychic Cylinder, Charles Wood’s Independograph, Charles F. Halsall’s Ajax Communicator,James Allan & Co.’s Pointer Planchette & Chart, Joseph Cundall’s Spiritualistic Message Indicator, and the Magna Jobson Research Centre’s Televox, all advertised alongside planchettes from S.W. Frost and Bournemouth Novelty Works, among others. Perhaps England’s greatest inventor, however, was Spiritualist Thomas Roden White, who created a host of apparatus for sale through his esoteric mail-order company, Psychic Stores. His obscure creations, almost always advertised simply and without illustrations, appeared throughout the decade in the pages of Psychic News, then one of the most popular newspapers catering to the esoterically-minded.

Alongside mainstays like Aluminum Luminous Slates, Psychaloid Séance Trumpets, automatic writing planchettes, and special lightweight tipping tables and bulbs for red light séances, White offered an array of apparatus like the Receptograph, the Messenger Spirit Indicator, and the Pendula. White’s Electrograph featured an electronic screen and a keyboard that was intended to be operated by the ectoplasmic appendages of a physical medium, while his Call-Bell attempted to capitalize on the popularity of the Vandermeulen Spirit Indicator.

Less is known about the operation or appearance of Old Black Joe’s Wheel, which promised to deliver messages “without any contact whatever,” or the Aetherian, a “miniature Ouija” with a celluloid indicator.

Unfortunately, as World War II began, Thomas White enlisted in the Royal Air Force Volunteer Reserve as a Pilot Officer to serve the war effort, and was killed in the Pacific theater during the Battle of Palembang on Valentine’s Day, 1942, bringing a sad end to one of Great Britain’s most prolific entrepreneurs of séance apparatus.