Chapter 2: The Great Planchette Craze

Planchettes might have forever languished as a minor spiritual curiosity, were it not for a late-1867 article published in England's Once a Week periodical.
This sensational 6-page story told of the writer's first encounter with a planchette, allegedly brought to the North of Scotland from American shores. Miraculous revelations received from multiple sittings with the device were recounted in great detail, and several illustrations accompanied the piece.
The article generated immediate interest in the "new" devices, after years of confinement to a backwater cottage industry. Letters poured in demanding to know where the items could be purchased, and the public's interest was immediately piqued. England’s sole planchette manufacturer, Thomas Welton, who claimed to have sold precisely 1,466 boards by this point, was hit with an onslaught of new competitors as booksellers and scientific instrument makers like Elliot Brothers rushed to meet demand.



Great Britain’s enthusiasm for the spirit-writing devices would pale in comparison to the voracious appetite of American consumers after the Once a Week article spread across the Atlantic and hit American newspapers the following year.
There, in the wake of the massive loss of life and a sustained period of mourning triggered by the Civil War, a new public appetite was awakened. As the article spread from paper to paper, stationery shops and booksellers in New England rushed planchettes into production to satisfy an intense public demand. Manufacturers like Cyrus H. Farley, Kirby & Co, Gilman Moulton, G.W. Cottrell, and N. Bangs Williams tried to assert themselves as preeminent and "original" makers of the devices in America, with some companies making false claims of having patent protections they had not actually acquired on the 15-year old devices that none of them had actually invented.
Buyers of planchettes were promised they could explore the exciting new spirit communication possibilities in the privacy of their own homes, and not rely on potentially fraudulent mediums that were by this time being continuously debunked by a press hungry for sensational journalism in the absence of battle.
A planchette séance circle with unknown participants, late 1860s. ►
Each new company seemed to offer a new design or an improvement on an old one. Kirby & Company began with wood planks with distinctive “scoops” cut from the back of their heart-shaped boards, but soon offered up plate glass and even India rubber models. Holmes & Company not only produced planchettes, but revived the dial plate ideas of Isaac Pease with alphabet boards that incorporated rotating disks as pointers. There were other refinements.
Ralph Jennings filed the first true planchette patent, with an unusual shape and beanie-style propeller as an "improvement" that he marketed as the Little Wonder. Bizarre attachments meant to insulate or charge the device with spiritual energy appeared, such as with Bangs William's bizarrely beautiful planchettes and their cast-metal "insulators."
Gilman Moulton followed suit with an alternating set of copper and nickel plates on his board's topside, meant to serve as a primitive battery. Manufacturers toyed with castor design and board shape, with each seeking to outdo the other with outrageous claims of one wood being more suited to spirit communication than another, or the lack of competitor's insulated castors making their products inferior.
Copycats were common, too, making modern identification of many planchettes difficult given the clandestine nature of the manufacturers. The innovation sustained demand, to great success for many, with Kirby & Co. claiming to have sold some 200,000 planchettes before the year was out.




Popular demand swiftly increased as the year wore on and newspapers continued to promote planchettes’ miraculous written communications.
New manufacturers appeared to capitalize on the craze, including C.O. French & Co., George H. Whitney, D.O. Goodrich, Lyman Baldwin, and C. & G.H. Drew, who offered their Improved Electric Planchette with brass wheels. G.W. Pitcher of Philadelphia offered at least two models, including an unusual 3-lobed variation and more traditional shapes that copied Kirby & Co.’s “scoop” design, while G.W. Cottrell’s neighbor William R. Hill of Boston introduced the Belgravia Planchette. Spiritualist publisher Bela Marsh offered planchettes in Banner of Light, while others offered alternative forms of spirit-spelling apparatus, including Cook’s Wonderful Alphabetical Combination Planchette, Charles Vaughn’s Electro-Magnetic Disc, and Walton Van Loan’s Pendulum Oracle, a simple wooden ball on a string paired with a “piece of circular pasteboard” printed with “the letters of the alphabet and various other characters and words” in concentric rings, in what may be the pendulums’ first commercial appearance as an alphabetic spelling indicator.



Planchettes’ grip on the public consciousness during this era is hard to overstate.
Books on the subject suddenly sprang up on both continents, from Kate Field's Planchette's Diary, said to be written entirely through the planchette itself, to popular writer Epes Sargent's Planchette, or, the Despair of Science.
The devices inspired hundreds of poems and many popular songs, including Planchette Polka, itself dedicated to Kirby & Co., who many considered the kings of planchette producers. Thousands of ads and articles proliferated in American newspapers, the wonders of the planchettes’ written communication growing more intense with each telling.
One article described how, once users’ fingers touched the board, it “becomes instinct with intelligence, writes answers to your questions, talks with you, tells the time of day, and does many other wonderful things,” though noted it would not work for the “skeptical or non-magnetic.” Another promoted planchettes as “the new thing, the latest wonder of the age,” warning readers they should experience the boards for themselves if they “do not wish to be behind the times.”
“Planchette Parties” became the most desirable of social gatherings, and whispers of the strange messages of the “Astounding Novelty” found planchettes “gaining rapidly in favor in fashionable circles,” including New York, where planchettes “now found in most all the Fifth avenue drawing-rooms.”

Thus was the First Great Craze of planchettes.
As the 1860s gave way to the 1870s, the popularity of the fad declined as well, and by the 1880s few of the original stationers and booksellers producing and offering the devices remained. Spiritualism began to change as well. A sensation-hungry public forced spirit mediums to deliver exponentially more sensational results in their sittings, with apports and physical materializations of spirits becoming more common.
As they pushed the boundaries of what a skeptical public was willing to accept, the media turned against the movement with a renewed vigor, reporting with glee every exposure and doubt, which grew more enthusiastic as time wore on. But new innovations in spirit apparatus continued, and slowly the automatic writing mechanics of planchettes began to merge with older styles of alphabetic communications, ushering in the age of the talking board.
Frontispiece for G.W. Cottrell’s Revelations of Planchette, 1868. ►