Chapter 1: The First Generation of Spirit Devices

Planchettes, talking boards, Ouija, and other spirit communication apparatus evolved during the latter half of the 19th-century, at a time when age-old religious notions found challenge in sweeping scientific discoveries and industrial advancements that rocked the firm footholds of faith.
A public primed by decades of macabre fascinations with mesmerists, psychic healers, ghost stories, and phantasmagorias plunged headlong into new religious territory when the young Fox Sisters claimed communion with spirits through the mysterious raps heard in their Hydesville, New York home in early 1848.
With the veil between the living and the dead seemingly parted, the belief in and experimentation with spirit communications spread at a rate previously unseen at the time, aided by advances in telegraph technology and a newly-cooperative media that spread news stories across the country like wildfire.
The virality of the Fox sisters’ fame and concepts of mediumship merged with the quasi-religious network established by their “Poughkeepsie Seer” precursor, the trance medium Andrew Jackson Davis, and adopted many tenants of the radical Quakers and Swedenborgians who formed the early core of true believers, eventually emerging as a belief system known as Spiritualism.
By 1851, only 3 years into the movement, one Philadelphia observer reported that some 50 or 60 séance circles had been formed in the city, while a Cincinnati newspaper editor estimated more than 1,200 mediums operating in his city alone. A grand new age of both science and religion was at hand—one that would find them again at the greatest odds, but also with a common enemy that threatened the sanctity of both.




With the establishment of the belief that spirits were willing and able to communicate with the living through special gifted mediums, enthusiasts quickly began to refine their communication methods.
Simple knocked affirmations to Yes/No questions or numbered responses quickly gave way to alphabet-calling, wherein the raps would select letters from a called-out alphabet in order to spell out messages one letter at a time. This method was further refined with the introduction of alphabet cards, where participants would run their finger or a pencil over a lettered card and wait for rapped responses to indicate letters and spell out messages.
Descriptions of these cards, particularly those used by famed medium Maria Hayden, were described as having two rows of letters and a row of numbers that predicted Ouija’s classic layout by nearly four decades.

By the early 1850s, séance enthusiasts began to experience strange, autonomous movements of their hands that forever changed the methods used to communicate with the dead.
Mediums like Isaac Post and Reverend Charles Hammond began to practice automatic writing, where their hands were seized by a possessive force to write spiritual messages, seemingly of their own volition. Others, like Edward P. Fowler, the chief medium of the influential New York Circle, became the first known direct writing mediums, in whose mere presence spirits “wrote manuscripts in different languages and Oriental characters without the aid of human hands,” and soon “writings upon paper or slates, without human contact” became a common feature of séances.
◄ Spirits both divine and malignant vie for control of an automatic writing medium’s hand in this depiction from De Morgan’s 1863 work From Matter to Spirit, superimposed on spirit writings of Sara Underwood, from her 1896 work Automatic or Spirit Writing.

Spiritualists who used alphabet cards to communicate began to experience similar seizures of their limbs, and members of Philadelphia’s First Circle described in early 1851 how, as participants’ hands passed repeatedly over a “card containing the alphabet in large letters,” they would perceive “an involuntary motion of the hand” they attributed to an “agency beyond the control of the medium.”
The group’s mediums quickly harnessed these strange sensations to spell out communications without waiting for raps, and this pairing of autonomously-moving indicators with alphabet cards served as the earliest incarnations of talking boards, in a startling display of mysterious movements that scientists now call the ideomotor response, or involuntary movements caused by the subject’s subconscious mind.
Around the same time, Spiritualists who followed A.J. Davis’ published instructions on how to conduct proper séances would form a “magnetic chain” with their hands placed in a circle atop a table.
Before long, these enthusiasts began to experience similarly strange movements of the furniture around which they gathered, as the tables seemed to tilt and turn of their own volition beneath their fingertips.
As news spread among séance circles, the fad of “table-tipping” became all the rage, as participants could now spread their outstretched hands on top of the nearest dinette, piano stool, or even top hat, and experience mysterious raps, unexplained tilting, and other strange movements as the objects exhibited seemingly intelligence responses to questions.
The popularity of the pastime was addictive and spread rapidly, and participants could even call the alphabet to the tipping table and receive tapped-out answers, which many believed to come from the spirits.
Even those along the western frontier were hooked, and in 1853, another journalist remarked that, "it was not by any means unusual on entering a log cabin to find the good, simple people seated around the rude table upon which the raps were being made."
Table-tipping and spirit rapping soon reached England and spread to the Continent, and on both sides of the Atlantic, inventive new ways to communicate with the "so-called dead" were imagined and made reality, and table-tipping became a worldwide craze.




Against this backdrop, homegrown spiritual experimentation and the invention of new methods of communication that harnessed these mysterious autonomous movements became the most popular of parlor pastimes.
One of the first was Isaac Burr Hartwell and Gaius Cobb of Woodstock, Vermont, who in January 1851 crafted a mechanical device described as having “36 keys like a Piano, 26 letters & 10 figures, so that the Spirits could communicate by rapping one and then another up in sight,” which they called Mr. Hartwell's Rapping Machine.
Around the same time, Oliver Fox of Wilson’s Grove, Iowa reported to the Spiritual Telegraph how his family utilized a complicated contraption consisting of a wall-mounted alphabet board and an indicator rigged with pulleys attached to a nearby table that spelled out messages on letter at a time as the table tipped up and down. In 1853, at the height of the table-tipping craze in Berlin, Germany, Adolphus Theodore Wagner invented a device he called the Psychographen or Thought Indicator, which worked something like a draftman's pantograph, with several jointed wooden slats controlled by multiple sitters who placed their hands on wood disks to manipulate the device, thus pointing out letters and numbers on an octavo-sized alphabet card placed below the indicator.





An early collaborator of Wagner was Mesmerist Daniel Hornung, who found himself in bitter competition with Wagner when he introduced his own spirit communication apparatus, which he called the Emanulektor.
While no images of the device have survived, the Emanulektor was described as a dial or disk with the alphabet and punctuation printed in one row, and numbers and arithmetic symbols in a second row, and featured an additional alphabet on the edge facing away from the user that allowed skeptical inquirers to test the accuracy of messages by obscuring the upper alphabet so the medium could not rely on sight to spell messages.
The original incarnation incorporated an indicator that rested on two rollers and pivoted on a small upright column mounted below the dial’s alphabet, rotating back and forth to indicate one letter at a time, which the user could adjust to point to either character set, with an interchangeable indicator designed to only point out letters on the hidden side of the dial.
Hornung and Wagner sparred bitterly in the press over their respective inventions, and each introduced automatic-writing versions of their apparatus, before Wagner fled Berlin and relocated to London, where he set up a showroom to demonstrate his remarkable apparatus, while also applying for a patent on the device, marking the world’s first attempt to patent a spirit communication tool.

In France, table-tipping enthusiasts attempted to harness the mysterious movements of the table in other ways. This led to a brief fad in tables ecrivantes, or writing tables, after some groups experimented with attaching pencils to table legs in an attempt to create spirit writing.
After being heavily lampooned in the press, these efforts were refined further on the evening of June 10, 1853, when participants at a table-tipping séance frustrated with their tedious communications received a message from an “invisible agent” to “fetch the little basket from the next room; fasten a pencil to it; place it upon a sheet of paper” before instructing them to “put your fingers on the edge of the basket."
Just as the tables had moved for the sitters, so too did the basket: “This basket, placed upon a sheet of paper, was set in motion by the same occult power that moved the tables; but, instead of obeying a simple and regular movement of rotation, the pencil traced letters that formed words, sentences, and entire discourses, filling many pages, treating of the deepest questions of philosophy, morality, metaphysics, psychology, etc., and as rapidly as though written by the hand.” Word of the writing baskets, or corbeilles écrivantes, spread to other séance circles, and by the end of 1853, Parisian craftsman had reimagined the baskets as small spirit-writing boards, or “little planks,” and the planchette was born.


The use of planchettes spread quickly across Paris, no doubt enhanced by the enticing and often sexually-charged idea of cooperative spirit communion, with men and women sitting in close contact, often in low-light, their hands intimately touching the board as they wrote out spirit messages.
By the end of 1853, their popularity sparked a pastoral letter written by the Bishop of Viviers, who railed against the use of planchettes by the clergy. A small cottage industry willing to provide this new tool took root in France and England, with scientific instrument makers such as Thomas Welton providing the devices to enthusiastic Spiritualists.
Meanwhile, other spirit communication devices had their time in the limelight, all briefly flaring before fading into obscurity.
John Rutter experimented with animal magnetism with his Magnetoscope, a pendulum device similar to later divination instruments.
Isaac Pease of Thompsonville, Connecticut, a tin plate worker, clockmaker, and enthusiast of the new table-tipping phenomenon, became the first in America to offer a commercial spirit communication apparatus with his introduction of his Spiritual Telegraph Dial after receiving a spark of inspiration “from the Spirit World.”
Designed for tabletop use, the Spiritual Telegraph Dial was a box of varnished black walnut designed to convert a tipping table’s movements into alphabetic communications. Its face was printed with a circular alphabet dial and an assortment of short phrases, with a clock hand centered on the dial that served as an indicator.
The indicator rotated by an internal spring-and-pulley mechanism powered by a long cord that emerged from the box and attached to a nearby weight or chair, turning around the dial as the user’s table tipped back and forth.


← J.O.N. Rutter’s Magnetoscope, 1854.

Famous chemist Dr. Robert Hare, inspired by Pease’s invention, constructed similar devices of his own, and modified some of Pease's dial plates to create foolproof machines meant to disprove spirit communication.
However, after testing some of the world’s most famous mediums using the apparatus, including Maria Hayden, the Fox sisters, Henry Gordon, Margaret Gourlay, and D.D. Home, the aging professor only succeeded in convincing himself of the truth of the tested mediums’ claims, and his resulting book, titled Experimental Investigation of the Spirit Manifestations or Spiritualism Scientifically Demonstrated, sent a shockwave across America as one of its most famous scientists publicly endorsed Spiritualism while claiming to provide evidence of the afterlife.
Spiritualists rushed to claim Hare’s work as scientific truth of their beliefs, while newspapers lampooned the dangers of Hare’s findings, illustrating chaotic séance chambers filled with “modern demoniacs” whose violence was the “inevitable consequences of Spiritualism” under the influence of Hare’s “immortal advisors.” Inspired by Hare’s efforts, famed English-Canadian author Susanna Moodie, a longtime friend of the Fox family, regularly engaged in séances with several alphabetic spirit apparatus created by her husband John Moodie, which he named Spiritoscopes.




The year 1858 marks a faithful milestone for spirit communication devices, when the planchette crossed the Atlantic into America. At this time, prominent Spiritualist, legislator, and social reformer Robert Dale Owen traveled to Paris, then London, then finally back to America, accompanied by his companion Dr. H. F. Gardner, himself a well-known Boston Spiritualist and paranormal investigator. Gardner's account, as related by his friend and planchette manufacturer G.W. Cottrell, later recounted in a letter dated May 5, 1859:
"In Paris, I witnessed a method of communication of which I had not heard in America. The instrument used by them they call a 'Planchette.' The method of communication is by writing...I called upon the manufacturers of the above-mentioned instrument to purchase one to take home with me, and he informed Mr. Owen, who was with me, that he had made and sold several hundred in Paris alone."
Early planchette enthusiast Robert Dale Owen, who, along with Dr. H.F. Gardner, imported several Parisian models to America in 1859. ►
The pair purchased six of the devices and returned to Boston with them. There, an unidentified Boston bookseller had 50 copies made of one of Gardner's planchettes with the intention of selling them, but by all accounts the spirit-writing devices failed to catch on.
Within a few short years, the immense distractions of the American Civil War took over the public consciousness, and media attention shifted to the more serious news of the war, even as séances became more sensational, with the rise of superstar mediums, physical manifestations, spirit photography, and spirit voices. But the planchette was waiting in the wings for its turn in the spotlight, and the curtains soon began to part to usher in the First Great Craze.