Elisha G. Selchow began his career as the young inheritor of a failing box factory founded by his German-immigrant father. Underage and in debt, he was unable to secure traditional lines of bank credit to stock his factory, but in a surprisingly cunning move borrowed on a cache of goodwill left by his father, securing small loans from neighboring businessmen in $100 and $150 amounts. Capital assured, he was able to rebuild his father's company, with one agent recording in 1864 that he was a "correct, reliable, industrious young man, underage, prompt in his payments and doing well."
In 1867, Elisha established his company to manufacture “Games of All Kinds,” and found its first success in late 1870 by capitalizing on the fortuitous failure of Albert Swift’s gaming firm, for whom Selchow had manfactured boxes. That company’s impending bankruptcy allowed Elisha to purchase their publishing rights to the popular parlor game, Parcheesi, and maintain ownership of this lucrative property throughout most of his company’s long existence. In the late 1870s, Selchow & Co. took advantage of a cyclical surge in interest for planchettes, and offered two style in their 1879-80 catalog, including one pitched as “the great mystery” was crafted of black walnut and sold to the trade for $7.50 per dozen, as well as “rubber planchette boards” that sold for $12.00 per dozen and hearkened back to Kirby & Co.’s innovative “India Rubber” planchette from the prior decade.
In this same period, Selchow partnered with a valued employee he had gained from his buyout of Albert Swift’s game company the previous decade: a talented young clerk and manager named John H. Righter. Righter brought considerable experience in the games industry, and Selchow brought him on as a full-fledged partner of the firm, which they renamed Selchow & Righter in 1880 to reflect the change. The company combined their box factory and gaming concerns under one roof and found great success through the manufacture and distribution of other firms’ games, in whole or in part, including Milton Bradley, Parker Brothers, and J. H. Singer, and the company assembled and packaged games distributed by them or licensed out their games to rebrand under the Selchow & Righter wholesale and retail banners. The company also created a network of trunk-toting salesmen known as “drummers,” enabling widespread promotion, sales, and distribution of their portfolio, and swiftly became a dominant force in a rapidly modernizing industry. The company had an estimated $300,000 in sales in 1884, and the following year reportedly sold 33,382 copies of Parcheesi alone. By 1886, the partners confidently claimed they kept “the largest assortment and most complete line of Games, Home Amusements, Out-door Sports, Blocks, Picture Books, and Novelties to be found in any Store in the United States,” and the claim was not without merit.
By 1885, the partnership’s planchette offerings expanded to three new models. There was the Planchette No. 1, a “handsomely decorated” board of polished ebony, with nickel-plated castors, “pivot watch step bearings,” and “non-conducting glass wheels,” that sold to trade clients for $18.00 per dozen. Their No. 2 board was crafted with a cherry finish, with swiveling nickel-plated castors and boxwood wheels that sold for $9.00 per dozen. Their No. 3 board was a budget board that sold for only $4.00 per dozen, made of varnished hardwood, with brass castors and maple wheels. All three came in the firm’s sturdy boxes with an illustrated label, a pencil, instructions, and a reprint of an article on the planchettes’ “wonderful workings” from the pages of Scientific American.
Two years later, the No. 1 planchette with glass wheels dropped from the catalog, and the cherry-finished board assumed its product name, with the budget board becoming the No. 2. Surviving planchettes from this period preserve the original shape inherited from Cottrell’s Boston Planchette, and labels carry the claim “From the Original Pattern first made in 1860;—(IMPROVED).” Selchow & Righter continued offering wholesale planchettes to the toy and board-game trade but advertised direct sales to the public as early as 1889, when advertisements for their boards appeared alongside solicitations for Parcheesi in the pages of popular Scribner’s Magazine
This design carried forward into the following year, when Ouija arrived on shop shelves acros America, and became a major sales success over the next two years. Planchettes were already resurgent when Ouija debuted, and as reports circulated about how “the planchette craze has struck,” their renewed media visibility created an alternate path for toy manufacturers to benefit from Ouija’s popularity without directly challenging its patent. Selchow & Righter remained the trade’s main planchette supplier, and quickly became one of Kennard Novelty Company’s earliest wholesale agents, listing Ouija in their trade catalogs as early as 1891, and were among the first to offer Kennard’s smaller-sized Ouija. Selchow & Righter rebranded their planchette as the Scientific Planchette around this time, which was now marketed with an “improved” form featuring a slightly sharper point and more pronounced curvature on its tail, whose labels kept the “From the Original Pattern—First Made in 1860” claim despite their departure from the original Boston Planchette shape, and the Scientific Planchette would remain on the market for several decades, and also be licensed and rebranded by E.I. Horsman, becoming perhaps the most recognizable American planchette of all time.
Selchow & Righter also produced a rarer version of the Scientific Planchette whose date of manufacture remains elusive. Called the “Mystic of Mystics,” the planchette is nearly identical in craftsmanship to the Scientific Planchette, but carries no label on its belly, and features a bright blonde finish on both sides of its board. The main difference is its box, which is a brightly-lithographed box featuring a trio of green spectres hovering over a pair of planchette-wielding hands. The illustration was likely copied from an identical drawing by Charles Winter that had accompanied a story on Spiritualism that circulated in American newspapers in 1907, but careful inspection of the box illustration reveals the name “Jensen” hidden in the folds of one spectre’s swirling ectoplasm. It is unknown which drawing came first, but it very likely dates the rare and elusive Mystic of Mystics planchette to around this period.
Selchow & Righter would produced planchettes for many decades, even after the passing of both company founders, and and Harriet Righter, John Righter’s eldest daughter, who served as company vice-president beginning in 1916, kept planchettes as part of the company’s offerings. This likely served them well during the 1920s Ouija craze, where Selchow remained an important Ouija distributor. Harriet, who was described as someone who “thought on a higher plane” and was “independent as hogs on ice,” substantially stepped up their Scientific Planchette advertisements in trade magazines, which soon dominated the retailer market. Unfortunately, while the company survived the Great Depression, planchettes evaporated from company catalogs in the wake of that great turmoil, leaving behind a legacy of some of the finest and most enduring planchettes ever produced in America.